• This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.
  • Assalamu Alaikum Warehmatullahi Wabarakatuhu Islaah e Ummat Forum Mein Aapka Isteqbaal Hai. Agar Aap Pehli Baar Forum Par Aaye Hain To Register Zaroor Karen Taaki Aap Forum Se Ziyadah Se Ziyadah Faida Utha Saken. Baghair Register Huwe Aap Islaah e Ummat Forum Par Posting Nahi Kar Sakenge. Is Liye Register Kar Ke Apna Account Bana Len Jo Ki Bilkul Free Hai. Registration Ka Tareeqa. Register Hone Ke Baad Aap Ko Aik Confirmation Email Aapki Us Email ID Par Bheji Jaayegi Jis Ko Aapne Account Banate Waqt Daala Tha. Kabhi Confirmation Email Aapko Milne Mein Thodi Late Bhi Ho Sakti Hai. Aap Ke Inbox Ya Phir Aap Ke Junk Mail Ya Spam Box Mein Yeh Confirmation Email Milega. Koi diqqat ho to hamein MAIL karen.

Imam ke peeche surah fatiha nahi padhne ki ahadees ka tehqeeqi jayeza

Joined
Apr 16, 2018
Messages
32
Likes
9
Points
9
Location
Mumbai
#1
Assalamualaikum warehmatullahi wa barakatuhu bhai mera sawaal hai ke kya yeh sab hadees sahih hai jo mundarja zel hai ⬇

1⃣Hazrat Jabir ra kehte hai ke jis ne bhi rakat padhi bina surah fatiha ke toh uski namaz nahi hui siwaye imam ke peeche (matlab imam ke peeche surah fatiha nahi padhna hai) (Jami At Tirmizi Hadees No.313)

2⃣ Hazrat zaid bin saabit ra kehte hai ke imam ke peeche qirat nahi hai chahe jehri (loud) ya sirri (silent) namaz ho.(Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah Hadees No.3787)

3⃣ Hazrat Abdullah ibn Umar r.a baar baar yeh kehte thhey ke jo imam ke peeche namaz padh raha ho toh imam ki qirat uskeliye kaafi. (Sunan Al Kubra Al Baihaqi Hadees No.2901)

Bhai kya yeh sab hadees sahih hai? Reference number ke saath jawab dein tafseel ke saath jazak allah
 
Joined
Apr 16, 2018
Messages
32
Likes
9
Points
9
Location
Mumbai
#2
Assalamualaikum warehmatullahi wa barakatuhu bhai mera sawaal hai ke kya yeh sab hadees sahih hai jo mundarja zel hai ⬇

1⃣Hazrat Jabir ra kehte hai ke jis ne bhi rakat padhi bina surah fatiha ke toh uski namaz nahi hui siwaye imam ke peeche (matlab imam ke peeche surah fatiha nahi padhna hai) (Jami At Tirmizi Hadees No.313)

2⃣ Hazrat zaid bin saabit ra kehte hai ke imam ke peeche qirat nahi hai chahe jehri (loud) ya sirri (silent) namaz ho.(Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah Hadees No.3787)

3⃣ Hazrat Abdullah ibn Umar r.a baar baar yeh kehte thhey ke jo imam ke peeche namaz padh raha ho toh imam ki qirat uskeliye kaafi. (Sunan Al Kubra Al Baihaqi Hadees No.2901)

Bhai kya yeh sab hadees sahih hai? Reference number ke saath jawab dein tafseel ke saath jazak allah
Assalaamualikum bhai ek hafta hogaya aap ne abhi tak jawaab nahi diye.
 

Umar Asari

Active Member
Staff member
Joined
Oct 30, 2016
Messages
1,193
Likes
2,951
Points
96
Location
New Delhi, India
#6
Assalaamualaikum bhai aaj 23 date hogayi aap ne abhi tak jawab nahi diye
Walaikum Assalam Wa Rehmatullahi Wabarakatuhu
Ji abhi bhi masroof hun. Sab ka jawaab likhne mein bahut waqt lagega. Aap is topic par Shaikh Irshad ul Haq Asari Hafizahullah ki kitaab padh len.
Aur agar ikhtisaar se jaanna hai to itna bata dun ki in mein kuch aasaar e sahaba sahih hain. Lekin Marfoo’ riwayat ke muqaable mein unko tarjeeh nahi de sakte. Khaas taur par aisi halat mein ki in mein se aksar sahaba se Surah Fatiha padhna sabit hai.
Wallahu A’lam.
 

Similar threads