Abdul Adil
Member
Kya Mard Aur Aurat Ki Namaz Me Farq hai ?
Muqallid Bhaiyyo Ki Pesh Kardah Hadees Ki Tahqeeq
Tehreer:- Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai
Rahimahullah
Romanised:- Syed Ibraheem
Salafi
___________________
Daleel number - 2
Ibne Umar (Raz.) Se Marfooan Naqal Kiya Gaya Hai Ke Aurat Jab Sajdah Kare To Apne Peit Ko Raano Se Chipka Le.
[Ibne A’adi]
Note :- Ye Hadees Sunan Al Bayhaqi Al Kubra 3/74 mei hai aayiye is hadees ki bhi tahqeeq karte hai
Tahqeeq :-
Pehli baat hai Ye Riwayat Behqi 3/74 me Hai
YAHYA Bin MOEN ne ise Zaeef Kaha
Iski sanad me ABU MOEET hai
1 jo Zaeef hai
2 hadise gharta tha
3 Murji Aur Kazzab Tha
4 Murjio ke sarganon me se tha
5 hadise waza karta aur sunan se adawat rakhta tha
6 Hadise zabt karne me nakara tha.
(mezan 1/11,575, mezanul A’tad 1/584 ,lisanul Mezan 2/334)
Dusri Baat Is Hadees ka Aur aik raawi hai Muhammad Bin Al-Qasim Al-Balakhi is Fabricator hai
Lissan Al-Mizzan (5/347) and Meezan Al Aitedaal
Teesri Baat Is hadees me aur aik raawi hai Ubaid Bin Mohammad Al-Sarkhi” ye majhol hai
Conclusion :- This hadith is fabricated Even Imam Bahayqi (rah) himself said about this and the next hadith after it ” Hadissan Zaeefan La Ya Hataj Ba Masa Laha
Muqallid Bhaiyyo Ki Pesh Kardah Hadees Ki Tahqeeq
Tehreer:- Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai
Rahimahullah
Romanised:- Syed Ibraheem
Salafi
___________________
Daleel number - 2
Ibne Umar (Raz.) Se Marfooan Naqal Kiya Gaya Hai Ke Aurat Jab Sajdah Kare To Apne Peit Ko Raano Se Chipka Le.
[Ibne A’adi]
Note :- Ye Hadees Sunan Al Bayhaqi Al Kubra 3/74 mei hai aayiye is hadees ki bhi tahqeeq karte hai
Tahqeeq :-
Pehli baat hai Ye Riwayat Behqi 3/74 me Hai
YAHYA Bin MOEN ne ise Zaeef Kaha
Iski sanad me ABU MOEET hai
1 jo Zaeef hai
2 hadise gharta tha
3 Murji Aur Kazzab Tha
4 Murjio ke sarganon me se tha
5 hadise waza karta aur sunan se adawat rakhta tha
6 Hadise zabt karne me nakara tha.
(mezan 1/11,575, mezanul A’tad 1/584 ,lisanul Mezan 2/334)
Dusri Baat Is Hadees ka Aur aik raawi hai Muhammad Bin Al-Qasim Al-Balakhi is Fabricator hai
Lissan Al-Mizzan (5/347) and Meezan Al Aitedaal
Teesri Baat Is hadees me aur aik raawi hai Ubaid Bin Mohammad Al-Sarkhi” ye majhol hai
Conclusion :- This hadith is fabricated Even Imam Bahayqi (rah) himself said about this and the next hadith after it ” Hadissan Zaeefan La Ya Hataj Ba Masa Laha